| Review |
|---|
| Review Comments* |
|
|
Evaluation Score* |
1. 2.5 Technological innovation and strategic relevance
Technological innovation that will be achieved at
the end of the project. Strategic relevance and expected impact for
Europe. |
| *
Please enter your comments |
|
|
|
|
2. 2.6 Business perspective or business plans
Does the proposal provide any aspects, concepts or approaches that could generate competitive new business?
|
| *
Please enter your comments |
|
|
|
|
3. Realistic degree of innovation with respect to the markets needs
Does the proposal provide any convincing innovation that could be considered as an answer to possible market needs?
|
| *
Please enter your comments |
|
|
|
|
4. Potentials for exploitation of the results
Is there any concrete potential that the ideas of the proposal could be exploited after the project has finished?
|
| *
Please enter your comments |
|
|
|
|
5. Feasibility, with reference to the proposed planning
Will there be sufficient visible results
within the proposed schedule? Is the proposed project plan feasible with
respect of timing, resource needs, and involved budget?
|
| *
Please enter your comments |
|
|
|
|
6. Quality of the proposed consortium
Are the proposed partners experienced and
competent enough to carry out the intended project plan? Are partners
missing that should be considered? Is the consortium well composed and
well balanced?
|
| *
Please enter your comments |
|
|
|
|
7. Value for money
Are the planned costs and effort acceptable and reasonable with regard to the intended results and the expected impact?
|
| *
Please enter your comments |
|
|
|
|
Summary comments and additional recommendations on the Proposal:
State below your main comments on the Proposal
(i.e. how do you consider the quality and value of the proposal and why
you have recommended/ not recommended it for Celtic project).*
|
| *
Please enter your comments |
|
|
The proposal may be re-submitted to the next Call
The proposal is currently not on an exceptable technical
level.
However the project idea is relevant and the proposal may be
re-submitted
to the next Celtic-Plus call
.
|
Required technical improvements in case of
re-submission to next Celtic-Plus Call
|
| *
Please enter your recommendations |
|
|
* Note: this field should
only be filled-in in case a re-submission of the proposal
to the next Celtic-Plus has been selected! |